Phil Kaplan uses litigation as a tool to help clients solve complex problems that interfere with their businesses.
Phil litigates a wide range of disputes, with an emphasis on commercial real estate litigation, shareholder litigation, and business-related appeals. In the real estate and shareholder arenas, Phil has represented clients in lawsuits involving lease interpretation and enforcement, land use, real estate purchases, shareholder buyouts, and fiduciary duties in privately-held companies. He has also represented clients in breach of contract, unfair competition, professional malpractice, employment, intellectual property, and trade secret cases.
Phil represents both plaintiffs and defendants. His clients include individuals, small businesses, and large corporations.
Phil has appeared in multiple state and federal courts and before arbitration panels. In addition to winning cases at the trial court level, he is an accomplished appellate lawyer, having successfully argued for his clients in several courts of appeal.
Phil recognizes that litigation is a means to an end — not an end in itself. From the beginning of each case, Phil works with clients to determine their ultimate business objectives and formulate strategies to effectively and efficiently meet those objectives. Phil has achieved favorable results for clients by keeping their individual goals in mind, rather than taking a one-size-fits-all approach to litigation.
Litigation is difficult and stressful, even when the law is on your side. Phil led our case with the highest level of expertise and professionalism. He is particularly skilled in persuasively arguing complex issues in a succinct manner. Engaging Phil Kaplan led to the finest outcome for which we could have hoped.
Cindy and Tim Monahan, client, 1800 Baxter County Road LLC
Submitted an amicus brief for Public Record Media in support of the appellant’s winning argument to the Minnesota Supreme Court about pleading damages for a Minnesota Government Data Practices Act claim.
Reversed the trial court’s dismissal of fraud claims made by Anthony Ostlund’s client.
Affirmed the trial court’s dismissal of all lender liability claims asserted against Anthony Ostlund’s client.
Affirmed a jury verdict in favor of Anthony Ostlund’s client on his claim for breach of a pre-incorporation agreement to share profits in a new business.
Affirmed the trial court’s decision to deny the defendants’ motion to compel arbitration of claims made by Anthony Ostlund’s client.
Reversed the trial court’s dismissal of claims Anthony Ostlund’s client made for fraudulent transfer of real estate.
Affirmed summary judgment for Anthony Ostlund’s client that a purported option to extend a lease was unenforceable.
Affirmed the trial court’s dismissal of all claims made by the University of Minnesota’s former associate women’s golf coach against Anthony Ostlund’s client, the former head golf coach.
Affirmed the trial court’s dismissal of shareholder claims asserted against Anthony Ostlund’s client.
Reversed the trial court’s dismissal of claims by Anthony Ostlund’s client that his co-shareholder was unfairly competing.
Represented a commercial landlord in a lawsuit to collect rent from a chain restaurant that continued to operate but refused to pay rent during the COVID-19 pandemic. Anthony Ostlund won summary judgment in one of the few judicial orders across the country - and possibly the first decision in Minnesota - determining a commercial tenant's obligation to pay rent during the pandemic.
Represented a commercial landlord in a breach-of-lease case and obtained over $1 million in awards for accelerated rent, late fees, interest, attorneys' fees and costs against the defaulting tenant.
Represented a subcontractor in an arbitration under the AAA Construction Rules to recover hundreds of thousands of dollars in payments that the general contractor was withholding. After an evidentiary hearing, the arbitrator awarded Anthony Ostlund's client nearly all of the damages it was seeking, plus interest and all of the attorneys' fees it paid for the case.
Represented the majority owners of a large agricultural company in Wisconsin in a shareholder dispute, which settled on a confidential basis after trial.
Represented Melanie Barry and Twin City Fan Companies in well-publicized, multi-faceted litigation against Charles Barry, including a divorce proceeding in Florida, an arbitration in Minnesota regarding Mr. Barry’s employment agreement, and multiple shareholder lawsuits in Minnesota state court. The parties reached a settlement agreement after months of discovery and motion practice and the issuance of a favorable special litigation committee report.
Defended the owner and developer of Mayo Clinic Square (formerly Block E) in Downtown Minneapolis in a lease dispute regarding our client’s redevelopment of the building and calculation of a tenant’s share of water bills. The parties reached a settlement agreement shortly before trial.
Pursued accounting malpractice claims against a Big Four accounting firm on behalf of a group of individual clients. Anthony Ostlund negotiated a favorable settlement for its clients after a two-week arbitration hearing.
Represented the owner of the Downtown East property across from the Metrodome, which included a Plaza used for Vikings game-day concessions and events. To resolve a dispute over the Minnesota Sports Facilities Authority’s current and future use of the property, Anthony Ostlund negotiated a purchase agreement that required the Authority to buy the property for $17.1 million, $12.6 million more than its tax-assessed value.
Represented the owner of the historic Pioneer-Endicott building in Downtown St. Paul in a dispute over damages a long-time tenant had caused to the building. The case settled after the trial court entered a key ruling in favor of Anthony Ostlund’s client on the proper measure of its damages.
Volunteer, Children's Law Center
Volunteer, Metropolitan Economic Development Association (MEDA)
Volunteer, University of Minnesota Business Law Clinic
Member, National Association for Industrial and Office Parks (NAIOP)
Officer, Hennepin County Bar Association Landlord-Tenant Section
Member, Minnesota State Bar Association – Appellate Practice Section
Member, Federal Bar Association
Closing Time: The Impact of Covid-19 on Bar and Restaurant Leases, Minnesota Lawyer and Finance & Commerce - Partner Content, March 2020
I want it all and I want it now: The enforceability of rent acceleration clauses, Minnesota Lawyer and Finance & Commerce - Partner Content, July 2019
Get Out: How to Force a Non-Statutory Buyout From a Company, Attorney At Law Magazine - Minnesota Edition, October 2018
Great, Now How Am I Supposed to Value an S Corp? Minnesota Lawyer - Partner Content, May 2018
Getting Credits (And Debits): Accounting Basics for Lawyers, Attorney at Law Magazine - Minnesota Edition, November 2017
Broker Beware: Get Your Commission Agreements in Writing, Minnesota Lawyer - Partner Content, April 2017
Of Landlords and Tenants: How Commercial Leases Can Go Awry, Attorney at Law Magazine - Minnesota Edition, August 2016
Developing Stories: A Primer on Building Height Restrictions, Attorney at Law Magazine - Minnesota Edition, May 2015
In Defense of Appraisers: Strategies for Minimizing Appraiser Liability Risk, Attorney at Law Magazine - Minnesota Edition, October 2014
Wild West 2.0 - How Attorneys are Solving Commercial Leasing Problems During the COVID-19 Pandemic, Hennepin County Bar Association, November 16, 2020
Representing a Landowner in the Context of a Stadium Development, Hennepin County Bar Association, December 12, 2013